‘Agree to disagree’ on the 3 Bank Street house

Print Article

This letter is to address the controversy surrounding the decision to demolish the home at #3 Bank Street in Wallace, a.k.a. the 1906 Mallon House. Rather than going through a whole point by point retort of the proceedings and history of the case, I have just a few things to say to set the record straight.

I’m the vice chair of Wallace’s Historic Preservation commission. As such I freely took on the duty to try to work out a compromise with the homeowners to keep this 112 year old home standing. All of my proposed compromises were rejected by the homeowners--as was their right. Those proposals included offers by local residents to donate time and treasure to keep the home from collapsing.

It is not in dispute that the home is in rotten shape. But demolition is not the only remedy. Here is the most expedient solution. Sell it.

That was the remedy that kept a historic home standing on the corner of Hotel and Seventh. That home was also in horrible shape, but once put on the market last year it sold almost immediately. New owners are renovating it in accordance with city historical codes.

That could be done in this case. In fact current homeowners could make a very tidy profit over the $10.00 (ten dollars) they paid for the 1906 Mallon House. Unfortunately they aren’t pursuing any other remedy but demolition.

I would have presented these points at the relevant P&Z Hearing in February, as I did in other P&Z hearings. I couldn’t attend though. I was ill; a case of shingles in my ear. I am still recovering six months after the initial attack. Searing ear and head pain coupled with nerve damage paralyzed my face, affected my speech, sapped my energy and restricted my schedule for months. Thus, I simply was not able to attend the Feb. 7th P&Z hearing that granted the homeowners a demolition certificate. I also would have presented these points at last night’s special hearing— but was muzzled by city officials and official procedure from speaking on the matter.

One last point. The loss of this historic home is not and should not be a death knell to either Wallace’s historic or overall congenial character.

In contrast to this case, many of Wallace’s historic homes and commercial buildings are now becoming more treasured. Both new residents and those returning to the community after a long absence have recently purchased several neglected properties and are restoring them.

What also should be valued is our sense of community. That is the real treasure of this town. It is the sense that we, for the most part, care about the place, the places and the people here. It would be a true shame to lose that sense of congeniality in this or any other controversy. I prefer to follow the advice of Ben Franklin. We can and should “disagree without being disagreeable.”

David Copelan,

Wallace

Print Article

Read More Letters to the Editor

Michelle Obama’s BECOMING best-seller

December 14, 2018 at 12:59 pm | Shoshone News-Press Michelle Obama’s ‘Becoming’ best-seller I’ve heard or read quite a bit of dissatisfaction, if not hatred, of Obama’s presidency, so I wonder how many will read the best-selling book by Michelle Ob...

Comments

Read More

Free community Ecumenical Christmas dinner

December 11, 2018 at 10:26 am | Shoshone News-Press Free community Ecumenical Christmas dinner Every year, some of the churches, in Osburn, Silverton, Wallace and Mullan host an Ecumenical Christmas dinner. Free for anyone who would otherwise not...

Comments

Read More

Here we go again!

November 16, 2018 at 1:04 pm | Shoshone News-Press Here we go again! Mitch McConnell Senate leader calls for bipartisanship with the new Democratic house. But lets not forget when Obama was elected president, McConnell said “Obama will be a one-t...

Comments

Read More

Half truths by the Hansens, vote Beehner for Commissioner

November 01, 2018 at 1:36 pm | Shoshone News-Press Yet again, another half-truth presented as fact by a member of John Hansen’s family. In December of 2017, Matt Beehner submitted a complaint to the State of Idaho Office of the Attorney General,...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 752-1120
620 E Mullan Ave.
P.O. Box 589
Osburn, Idaho 83849

©2018 Shoshone News Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X