CHUCK MALLOY: Congress returns to pleas for more gun laws

Print Article

Do something.

Members of Congress have been hearing that line plenty of times plenty during the August recess, and since those horrific mass shootings in Texas and Ohio.

Now that Congress is back in business, the volume has been turned up a few notches for representatives and senators to “do something” to end these senseless mass shootings and make our country a safer place.

Trouble is, there’s no clear consensus over what can be done — or whether a government solution is even possible. The creative thinkers on Capitol Hill — who can’t seem to agree on the color of the sky on a given day — have yet to figure out a way to effectively legislate against crazy. Killing people is against the law, but the crazies ignore that, too.

“We’ve gotten some of these calls (to do something), and people are crying out,” said Idaho Congressman Russ Fulcher. “Everybody hurts when these shootings happen, and I hurt too. If I felt confident that I could solve it, or we could solve it, then I’d be all in. But it’s more complicated than that.”

There is no simple solution. During a recent visit to Washington, I asked Idaho Sen. Jim Risch if he could draft such a bill. “I’m not a magician. I couldn’t do it, and I don’t know anybody who could,” he said. “We have a constitutional provision, and it was so important to our Founding Fathers that they included it in the Bill of Rights.”

Idaho’s congressional delegation is hardly the place to start talking about gun control. All four Republicans are staunch supporters of the Second Amendment, and an endorsement from the National Rifle Association is like money in the bank in terms of getting votes. They win elections by healthy margins partly — if not largely — because of their views on guns. The members might be open to a watered-down measure that makes it appear that Congress is “doing something,” but not at the expense of bruising relations with the NRA. That’s no criticism of the congressional delegation … it’s just Politics 101 in Idaho.

But there is one area where Idaho Republicans can line up with the gun-control advocates.

“I don’t know of anyone who thinks that people who are mentally disturbed should be able to buy firearms,” Risch said. “We all start out in the same place in that regard, but it gets complicated after that because there’s 99.9 percent of the people who have a constitutional right to own firearms.”

Risch and Fulcher agree that the problem with mass killings will not go away, even if Congress takes the bold step of banning guns in all forms — and they have a point.

“China is having a problem with serial knifings,” Fulcher said. “People who are sick, or are not right mentally, are going to figure out a way to do damage — whether it’s a knife, a car or a truck with fertilizer in the back. I’m not going to be on the front end of restrictions on the Second Amendment.”

As Fulcher sees it, the dialogue must go beyond the halls of Congress.

“Government can’t do everything, and it wasn’t expected that it can do everything. How do you legislate against crazy? We are a product of our culture, and our culture is not healthy,” Fulcher said.

“We are not going to solve this until we can figure out how to touch the hearts and minds of people who are causing the problem,” he said. “My solution is, and nobody is going to like it, is that people need to do more to help each other — whether it’s through neighborhoods, churches or community groups.”

Congress is not going to be able to find, or reach out, to mentally disturbed people who should not be toting semi-automatic weapons with magazine sizes that can mow down masses of people in seconds. But through community efforts, then maybe — just maybe — there is a chance that would-be shooters can get the help they need. And if people keep their eyes open, maybe police can catch some of these crackpots who make threats on social media.

Fulcher is right. He’s not talking about feel-good solutions that folks want to hear. But pro-active efforts outside the political arena may be the only option that’s available once we all realize that neither Congress, nor government, have the magic answers.

• • •

Chuck Malloy, a longtime Idaho journalist and Silver Valley native, is a columnist with Idaho Politics Weekly. He may be reached at

Print Article

Read More Columns

BOOK REVIEW: AMERICAN COPPER by Shann Ray (fiction, 2015)

October 21, 2019 at 11:50 am | Shoshone News-Press This is a story set in the Montana copper mining country around Butte. It has little to do with the mining industry but focuses on several people involved in it. Josef Lowry, “the Baron”, is a p...


Read More

Risch speaks no evil of President Trump

October 21, 2019 at 11:47 am | Shoshone News-Press Sen. Jim Risch of Idaho, who chairs the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, is accustomed to getting questions from the media. But there are a couple of ground rules that he is exercising these days....


Read More

Impeachment talk rages; other work stalls

October 07, 2019 at 10:50 am | Shoshone News-Press In Washington politics, the shrill voices are the ones who tend to get heard, but it’s those who are trying to stay above the fray – such as Idaho Sen. Mike Crapo – who are trying to deal with some...


Read More

Risch to Idahoans: Read transcript, then decide

September 30, 2019 at 10:52 am | Shoshone News-Press Idaho Sen. Jim Risch chairs the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and is the No. 2 figure on the Select Intelligence Committee, which means he has access to President Trump – and lots of clout to ...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 752-1120
620 E Mullan Ave.
P.O. Box 589
Osburn, Idaho 83849

©2019 Shoshone News Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy